Should I Take the New SAT or the ACT?
Published on: by SupertutorTV
- Introduction
- Introduction to new SAT vs ACT
- Reasons to take the ACT over the SAT
- Taking a prep class - potentially better tutors for the ACT
- Weak in writing or reading comprehension - ACT may be easier
- Reasons to take the SAT over the ACT
- Free SAT prep available on Khan Academy
- Bad at science section of the ACT
- Struggle with time management - SAT may be a better fit
- Potential to become a National Merit Scholar
- Cases where it doesn't matter which test to take
- 2. Scores are about equal and only doing modest self prep
- 3. Have a skilled professional tutor to guide prep
- Highlights
- FAQ
- See Also
Introduction
Hey everyone, this is Brooke with SuperTutorTV and today we're going to talk about whether you should take the new SAT or the ACT. This is a question I've been getting a lot. The first thing that I want to do is make a quick disclaimer: if you are a senior graduating in 2016, this video is not for you. You should be watching another video, which is the old SAT vs. the ACT. But for everybody else, for everyone who's graduating in 2017 and beyond, you, as students, are going to be subjected to an experiment by the College Board, which is a new test, which has new emphases, which has new styles of questions, and a lot of people in the test prep community have basically responded to this change in the test by saying, "everybody should just prep for the ACT, forget about the SAT!" Now, while that might be okay advice for some students, I don't think it's the right answer for 100% of people. So what I'm going to do is get into this conversation and talk to you about some situations in which it may actually be better for you to take the ACT than the SAT, as well as some situations in which it might be better for you to take the SAT instead of the ACT.
Introduction to new SAT vs ACT
Hey everyone, this is Brooke with SuperTutorTV and today we're going to talk about whether you should take the new SAT or the ACT. This is a question I've been getting a lot. The first thing that I want to do is make a quick disclaimer: if you are a senior graduating in 2016, this video is not for you. You should be watching another video, which is the old SAT vs. the ACT, we can put that link up right here. But for everybody else, for everyone who's graduating in 2017 and beyond, you, as students, are going to be subjected to an experiment by the College Board, which is a new test, which has new emphases, which has new styles of questions, and a lot of people in the test prep community have basically responded to this change in the test by saying, "everybody should just prep for the ACT, forget about the SAT!"
Now, while that might be okay advice for some students, I don't think it's the right answer for 100% of people. So what I'm going to do is get into this conversation and talk to you about some situations in which it may actually be better for you to take the ACT than the SAT, as well as some situations in which it might be better for you to take the SAT instead of the ACT.
AdmitGPT: Your Personal College Admissions AI Assistant
Get tailored college recommendations, essay feedback, interview prep, and more.
Try it nowReasons to take the ACT over the SAT
The number one reason that you should take the ACT instead of the SAT is if you are going to be an insane prepper. If you are going to put your pedal to the metal, you are going to spend an inordinate amount of time prepping for this test, and you want to take every example test humanly possible that you can, you want to look at as many prep books as you can, you want to learn all the secrets of the test, and you're going to just go for it. There are so many ACTs, old ACTs, that are available for download so if you're looking to really get a ton of real tests in front of your face, and really get to know the test well, you're going to have a few more materials to work with.
The other reason why you might want to take the ACT is if you're going to take a prep class. If you're going to a place like the Princeton Review or Kaplan or - I don't know what companies your town has. There's probably some smaller tutoring companies. I generally recommend smaller tutoring companies over the big ones. Sometimes those teachers are going to have a lot more experience tutoring the ACT, and so they might be better at tutoring the ACT than tutoring the SAT. And finally, the third reason that you might want to take the ACT and not the SAT is that you're bad at writing or reading comprehension. If those are the two areas that you struggle with the most, generally the ACT version of those two sections is a little bit easier to conquer than the SAT, though really it does come down to: in what way do you struggle with that?
Taking a prep class - potentially better tutors for the ACT
One of the reasons why it might be better for students to take the ACT instead of the SAT is if they are planning on taking a prep class. When considering which test to prepare for, students should take into account the quality of the tutors available for each test. Larger test prep companies like Princeton Review or Kaplan may offer classes for both the SAT and ACT, but smaller tutoring companies might have tutors with more experience specifically in ACT preparation. These tutors could potentially provide more tailored guidance and support for students aiming to excel in the ACT.
Another advantage of taking a prep class for the ACT is that the teachers may have extensive experience in tutoring students for this particular exam. The ACT has its own unique format and question types, so having instructors who are well-versed in these specifics can be beneficial for students looking to boost their scores. Additionally, the focus of the prep class may align more closely with the content and strategies needed for success on the ACT, making it a more targeted and efficient preparation option.
Overall, students who are considering enrolling in a prep class to prepare for a standardized test like the ACT should weigh the expertise of the instructors, the resources available, and the overall suitability of the class for their learning style and goals. Taking the ACT prep class may be advantageous for students who prefer structured learning environments, benefit from personalized instruction, and are aiming to maximize their performance on the ACT exam.
Weak in writing or reading comprehension - ACT may be easier
For students who struggle with writing or reading comprehension, another reason to consider taking the ACT over the SAT is the potentially easier nature of these sections on the ACT. While both tests assess reading and writing skills, the ACT may offer a more straightforward approach or question style that could be more manageable for students who find these areas challenging. Understanding the specific areas of weakness can help students decide which test to focus their preparation efforts on.
In the reading and writing sections of the ACT, students may encounter passages and prompts that are more aligned with their comfort level or skill set, allowing them to perform better in these areas compared to the corresponding sections on the SAT. By identifying their strengths and weaknesses in reading and writing comprehension, students can make an informed choice about which test plays to their strengths and offers the best opportunity for improvement.
In conclusion, students who struggle with writing or reading comprehension should consider the potential advantages of taking the ACT, as the test may offer a more favorable testing environment for these specific skill areas. By assessing their individual proficiency in reading and writing, students can determine whether the ACT's approach and content align better with their strengths and learning preferences, ultimately leading to a more strategic decision in their test preparation process.
Reasons to take the SAT over the ACT
While there are compelling reasons to consider taking the ACT, there are also situations where students might find it more beneficial to focus on the SAT instead. One significant advantage of choosing the SAT is the availability of free prep resources from Khan Academy. For students who may not have the financial means to invest in a prep class or private tutor, the free SAT prep offered by Khan Academy can be a valuable resource to improve their test performance.
Additionally, students who struggle specifically with the science section of the ACT may find the SAT to be a better fit for their strengths. If the science portion of the ACT poses a significant challenge or inconsistency for a student, opting for the SAT could alleviate some of the pressure associated with that particular section of the test. Understanding one's weaknesses and targeting them effectively is crucial for optimizing test scores.
Another reason to consider taking the SAT over the ACT is if time management is a significant issue for a student. The SAT's timing structure may be more conducive to students who struggle with pacing themselves during standardized tests. By selecting the SAT, students can potentially alleviate some of the time-related stress and focus more on answering questions accurately within the allotted time frame. Overall, students should assess their individual needs, strengths, and weaknesses to determine whether the SAT offers a more favorable testing experience and better chances for success.
Free SAT prep available on Khan Academy
One of the top reasons why you might want to consider taking the SAT over the ACT is the availability of free test prep materials from Khan Academy. For students who may not have the financial resources to invest in classes or private tutoring, the online resources provided by Khan Academy can be a valuable asset. The convenience and accessibility of these resources make it a compelling option for students looking to prepare for the SAT without breaking the bank.
Khan Academy's free SAT prep offers a wide range of study materials, practice tests, and personalized study plans to help students improve their test scores. With tailored lessons and feedback based on students' performance, the platform provides a comprehensive and effective way to prepare for the exam. By taking advantage of these resources, students can enhance their test-taking skills and increase their chances of achieving their target scores on the SAT.
Overall, the availability of free SAT prep materials from Khan Academy makes it a favorable choice for students who are self-motivated and looking for flexible study options. With the convenience of online learning and the quality of resources provided by Khan Academy, students can confidently prepare for the SAT and strive for academic success.
AdmitGPT: Your Personal College Admissions AI Assistant
Get tailored college recommendations, essay feedback, interview prep, and more.
Try it nowBad at science section of the ACT
If you struggle with the science section of the ACT, it may be worth considering taking the SAT instead. The science section of the ACT can be challenging for some students, particularly those who are not as well-versed in scientific concepts or data interpretation. In comparison, the SAT does not have a dedicated science section, which may alleviate some of the stress and difficulty associated with the ACT's science portion.
By opting to take the SAT, students who find the science section of the ACT particularly daunting can focus their efforts on preparing for other sections of the test. Whether through online resources like Khan Academy or traditional prep classes, students can tailor their study plans to strengthen their skills in areas where they feel more confident and capable. Ultimately, choosing the SAT over the ACT can provide a more conducive testing environment for students who struggle with the science component of standardized exams.
In summary, if you have historically faced challenges with the science section of the ACT, exploring the option of taking the SAT instead could be a strategic decision to enhance your overall testing experience. By leveraging your strengths and prioritizing your academic growth, you can approach the SAT with a sense of readiness and confidence that may lead to better performance outcomes.
Struggle with time management - SAT may be a better fit
For students who grapple with time management during standardized tests, the SAT may offer a more suitable testing experience compared to the ACT. The ACT is known for its strict time constraints, requiring students to complete sections within specific time limits. This can pose a significant challenge for individuals who struggle to pace themselves effectively or who feel pressured by time constraints while testing.
In contrast, the SAT provides a slightly more relaxed timing structure, allowing students more time per question on average compared to the ACT. This additional time can be beneficial for those who need extra moments to process information, double-check their answers, or strategize their approach to challenging questions. By choosing the SAT, students who struggle with time management can potentially mitigate the impact of time-related stress on their overall test performance.
In conclusion, if time management has been a persistent issue for you during standardized testing situations, shifting towards the SAT as opposed to the ACT may offer a more accommodating testing environment. By capitalizing on the extended time allowances and adjusting your test-taking strategies accordingly, you can optimize your performance and minimize the negative effects of time pressure on your scores.
Potential to become a National Merit Scholar
One key reason why you might want to consider taking the SAT over the ACT is if you have the potential to become a National Merit Scholar. Achieving this prestigious status requires scoring in the top one-half to one percentile, or even the top one percentile on the PSAT. If you are already a top performer on standardized tests and believe that with enough preparation you could excel on the PSAT, then focusing your efforts on the SAT may be the right choice for you. By dedicating your time and resources to mastering the SAT, you may increase your chances of becoming a National Merit Scholar and opening up new opportunities for your academic future.
Additionally, if you are planning to take both the PSAT and SAT exams, it may be more beneficial to focus on preparing for the SAT rather than splitting your efforts between the SAT and ACT. By concentrating on one test format, you can streamline your preparation and maximize your performance potential. This targeted approach can be especially advantageous for high-achieving students who are aiming for top scores and national recognition through programs like the National Merit Scholarship competition.
Ultimately, the decision to pursue the SAT as a pathway to becoming a National Merit Scholar should be based on your academic goals, test-taking abilities, and commitment to rigorous preparation. By weighing these factors carefully and considering the potential benefits of achieving top scores on the SAT, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your aspirations for academic success and recognition.
Cases where it doesn't matter which test to take
In some cases, the choice between taking the SAT or the ACT may not significantly impact your overall test performance or college admissions prospects. One such scenario is when you plan to walk into the test without any preparation whatsoever. While this approach is generally not recommended due to the competitive nature of standardized testing, for some individuals, their natural abilities and test-taking skills may allow them to perform equally well regardless of the test format.
Another situation where the choice of test may not matter as much is when your scores on both the SAT and ACT practice exams are relatively equal, and you only intend to engage in modest self-preparation. If you are confident in your ability to perform consistently on both exams and prefer a minimalistic approach to test prep, then selecting either the SAT or ACT based on personal preference or logistical convenience may be a viable option.
Furthermore, if you have access to a highly skilled professional tutor who can provide personalized guidance and support, the decision between the SAT and ACT may become less critical. With expert tutoring and targeted assistance, you can enhance your test-taking skills and strategies to perform at your best on either exam. By leveraging the expertise of a private tutor, you can navigate the test preparation process more effectively and maximize your chances of achieving your desired scores.
2. Scores are about equal and only doing modest self prep
If your scores on practice exams for both the SAT and ACT are about equal and you are not planning on doing extensive preparation for either test, it may not make a significant difference which one you choose. In this scenario, you can focus on other factors such as test format preferences and content areas you feel more comfortable with.
Taking practice exams for both the SAT and ACT can give you a better idea of which test you feel more confident in and perform better on. Since the SAT and ACT have different question types and formats, it is essential to experience both tests to make an informed decision. Additionally, familiarity with both exams can help you determine if one test is more suited to your strengths and testing style.
Ultimately, if your scores are relatively equal and you are only engaging in modest self-preparation for the exams, you have the flexibility to choose between the SAT and ACT based on other considerations. Taking full-length practice exams for both tests can provide valuable insights that guide your decision-making process.
3. Have a skilled professional tutor to guide prep
If you have access to a highly skilled professional tutor who can provide personalized guidance and instruction, this can be a significant factor in determining whether to choose the SAT or ACT. A knowledgeable tutor with experience in both exams can help you identify your strengths and weaknesses, develop targeted study plans, and improve your test-taking strategies.
Working with a professional tutor can enhance your preparation process and boost your confidence for either the SAT or ACT. The tutor can offer valuable insights, resources, and feedback to help you maximize your scores on the chosen exam. Their expertise can make a difference in your overall performance and help you navigate challenging sections more effectively.
Having a skilled tutor by your side throughout your preparation can be particularly beneficial if you are aiming for specific score goals, struggling with certain test sections, or seeking personalized support in your test-taking journey. Their guidance and expertise can play a crucial role in helping you achieve your desired outcomes on either the SAT or ACT.
AdmitGPT: Your Personal College Admissions AI Assistant
Get tailored college recommendations, essay feedback, interview prep, and more.
Try it nowHighlights
- Taking the ACT may be beneficial if you are a dedicated and thorough prepper, with access to a wide range of practice materials.
- Consider taking the ACT if you plan to enroll in a prep class, especially with experienced tutors for the ACT.
- If you struggle with writing or reading comprehension, the ACT may offer a more manageable challenge compared to the SAT.
- The SAT could be a preferable option if you prefer online resources and free prep materials like Khan Academy.
- If you find the science section of the ACT challenging, switching to the SAT might be a strategic move.
FAQ
A: Key factors to consider include your prep strategy, comfort level with different test sections, and aspirations for competitive exams.
A: Taking full-length practice exams for both the SAT and ACT can help you assess your performance and preferences to make an informed decision.
A: Yes, for example, if you excel in time management, the SAT could be a better fit due to its time constraints compared to the ACT.
A: While it is possible to switch between tests, it is recommended to thoroughly prepare for the chosen test to maximize your potential score.
A: Tools such as concordance tables, practice exams, and guidance from experienced tutors can aid in making an informed choice between the SAT and ACT.
See Also
Top Mistakes to Avoid When Transferring Colleges
Tips for Dealing with College Deferral
Building an Article from Video Transcript